Who is Self Insurance Services, LLC?

Self Insurance Services, LLC is dedicated to assisting you with the demands of your insurance needs. We offer a variety of quality plans to give you the confidence that is needed to protect your employees and family. Our years of experience in the insurance industry will assure you that Self Insurance Services, LLC is a different kind of company with a mission that is client centered.

Self Insuranace Services, LLC is based in Newburgh, Indiana servicing Evansville and the surrounding Tri-State area. We are small enough to give you one on one customer service yet big enough to provide you with access to most major carriers.

Self Insurance Services, LLC provides great coverage in Employee Benefits, Health Insurance, Disability Insurance, Life Insurance, Homeowners Insurance, Auto Insurance, Dental & Vision Insurance, Renters Insurance, and much more. Based out of Newburgh, Indiana and client-centered, Self Insurance Services, LLC LLC is excited to provide desired insurance plans for the drivers, homeowners, renters, business owners, and patients of Newburgh, Evansville, and the tri-state. Whether you desire car insurance, medical insurance, business insurance, condo insurance, home insurance, critical illness insurance, or other insurance options, allow us at Self Insurance Services, LLC to research the right option that fits your needs

Get To Know Us

Charles E. Self - LUTCF: Principal Agent, Property, Casualty, Life & Health

Charles opened Self Insurance Services, LLC in January of 2004 as a scratch agency and provided Employee Benefits from small to large corporations. Charles began offering property and casualty insurance to his customers in 2010. Since that time, the agency has grown mega in volume throughout the states of Indiana, Kentucky, Illinois, and Tennessee. Charles strives to not only win with our pricing, but to go beyond and provide the absolute best in service. Charles has qualified for numerous company sponsored trips from exceeding production requirements, numerous awards, and recognition. Charles enjoys spending time with his children, coaching their sports teams, attending concerts, collegiate and professional sporting events, and travel.

Educational background includes Brownstown Central High School in Brownstown Indiana, Ivy Tech State College in Columbus, IN, and the American College of Financial Services.

Angie Petts - Life & Health Enrollment Specialist

Angie was born in Illinois and grew up in Vincennes, IN. Graduated from the Business College in 1981. Angie worked as a claims processor for an Insurance company, then became a licensed insurance agent for Life, Health, Property & Casualty.

Angie began her insurance career with United Insurance Company of America where she sold and serviced accounts for life and health insurance. Angie left UIC with 20 years of service. At that time she then joined Monumental Life Insurance Company in 2001. The company then merged with Transamerica Life Insurance. With 17 years of service, Angie finished as the #1 agent in the country in 2013, and then again in 2014.

She truly has a passion for the business and willingness to strive to achieve the insurance needs of prospective clients.

Candice Orndorff - Property & Casualty, Life & Health Insurance

Candice's journey into the insurance industry was guided by a strong desire to help others and a natural inclination for engaging conversations. While her career didn't begin in insurance, her commitment to helping people led her here. Holding her Property & Casualty, as well as Life & Health licenses since 2019, Candice has been dedicated to making insurance accessible and understandable. Her approach is grounded and relatable, prioritizing customer service above all else. When you collaborate with Candice, you'll experience her knack for simply explaining coverages, ensuring you're well-informed about what you invest in. Beyond her professional role, Candice was born and raised in Owensboro, Kentucky and moved to Evansville's Northside in 2017. Candice is also a wife and mother of four, always open to discussing mom life, all things Peloton, latest book reads (fiction or nonfiction), and she is always happy to share a good laugh over funny memes. She enjoys traveling and attending as many concerts as possible! Her ultimate aspiration is to help protect her clients comprehensively against life's expected and unexpected events.

Hannah Wilson - Property & Casualty Agent

Hannah Wilson was born and grew up on the Northwest side of Evansville In. She attended Reitz High School and Ivy Tech Community College. She has experience in many backgrounds, got into the insurance field in 2012 and received P&C license shortly after. Loves interacting with people and is enthusiastic about educating them on insurance needs. She spends most of her time with her family.

Enjoys being active outdoors, socializing with friends, music, learning new things, and traveling when she can.

Will McEuen - Senior services & Life Insurance

Will McEuen has 20 years of experience in insurance and financial services. He lives in Evansville with his wife of 25 years. He has built three successful agencies since 2008 and recently merged River City Insurance with Self Insurance Services. His primary focus has been on personal and commercial insurance, but he is now focused on senior services and life insurance. Regardless of lines of insurance, Will has put emphasis on value and service. He strives to provide the best possible premium and service for the best possible coverage!

When Will isn't working, he enjoys time with his family, fishing, gardening, and hunting. He also has a passion for helping others, including helping on housing projects as well as volunteering for the local food bank.

Crystal Sutton - Property & Casualty Agent

Crystal is from Boonville, Indiana and graduated from Boonville High School and Indiana Business College. She began her career in Insurance in 2002 and joined Self Insurance in 2020. She enjoys talking with our clients and educating them on their coverages. In her spare time she enjoys spending time with her family, reading and being outdoors.

Donnie Turpin - Property & Casualty Agent

Donnie is a lifelong Evansville resident. Graduating from Evansville Reitz and attended Vincennes University and University of Southern Indiana. Donnie spent 17 years in the automotive sales industry in sales and management. Since then he has been proudly taking care of his customers as an insurance professional, offering auto, homeowners, among other insurance services with Self Insurance Services, LLC out of our downtown Evansville office at 225 Court Street Evansville, IN. 47708. Donnie and his wife of over 30 years have 2 daughters and 2 grandchildren. He enjoys spending valuable time with family.

Rita Williams - Property & Casualty Agent

Rita is an Evansville native and graduated from Mater Dei High School. She started her insurance career in 2010 at Torres Insurance as an Account Manager. Rita helps clients with servicing policies, making changes and providing certificates, etc. She has continued to develop relationships with clients at Self Insurance Services, LLC since 2019. She enjoys spending time with her family. Rita's hobbies include making candles and volunteering with Another Chance for Animals, which she donates part of her sales from candles to their organization.