Property Insurance

Your belongings. Safe.

Casualty Insurance

Stay safe on the road.

Business Insurance

Your company. Secure.

Life Insurance

Families, financially stable.

Start taking proper protections with your family, property, and more.

Many people undervalue how important good insurance is to keeping you and your family financially stable. The key is to protect today, for a better tomorrow.

Please fill in your phone number.

Our Most Popular Services By Category


Trusted Brands We Work With

Erie Logo Foremost Logo Nationwide Logo Progressive logo Safeco Logo Travelers Logo Universal Property Logo AIG Logo Grange Logo Hastings Mutual Logo Liberty Mutual Logo State Auto Logo

"We have our auto, home and business insurance with Self Insurance Agency and are very pleased with their service and rates. They even provide our drone insurance for our video company! Self Insurance is wonderful and we're happy that they're our insurance company."

Joe and Laurie Manor
ICR Advertising and Productions

"I highly recommend Self Insurance Services. Our family is pleased with the competitive pricing they offer for home, auto, boats, and business insurance needs. I appreciate the customer service that is offered and personal touch that they share with our family. Having an insurance agent touching base on insurances that may need to be changed due to changes in our life even before we consider the needs is truly priceless. Thank you to Chuck, Cindy, and Carol for the great customer service! I would highly recommend Self Insurance Services for insurance needs."

Lynn Ogle

"Charles Self and his team at Self Insurance Services, LLC has been a great find for my personal insurance, as well as my businesses. They saved me 50% off my personal vehicles and a significant amount below other quotes when I bought my new home. For my businesses and other commercial properties, they were well below the competition and on some policies as much as a 50% in savings for those as well. I highly recommend anyone looking to save money on their home, auto, or commercial insurance policies. The service is excellent and we're encouraged to call Mr. Self on his personal cell phone after hours or even on weekends if needed."

Kerry "KC" Chesser, Newburgh, IN
Owner, KC's Time Out Lounge, KC's Corner Pocket, and KC's Marina Pointe

"My wife and I recently switched our home and auto policies to Chuck Self with Self Insurance Services. Chuck walked us through the entire process, helped us improve our policy coverages and managed to save us $200 annually. Chuck and his team are so honest and helpful and full of integrity. We were so happy with our results that we immediately switched our business auto policy as well. Chuck saved us $2000 annually while improving our coverage to protect our business interests. If you are looking for an insurance agency that is locally owned and who's staff is helpful and friendly, call Chuck Self with Self Insurance Services and you'll be glad you did."

Charlie McMahon, Evansville, IN
McMahon Exterminating, Inc.

"We have partnered with Self Insurance since 2013 for our health, dental, and vision coverage for employees. Charles Self has always been responsive to our needs and with any questions that our staff members have. Charles takes the extra step to understand our business needs and match those needs with the best and most affordable products. The ket to the relationship is that Charles truly provides great service to us. He is available when we need him and always has a quick response to our questions.

Barbara Winstead, Newburgh, IN
Heritage Federal Credit Union

"My wife and I insure everything from our business, home, auto, boats, and motorcycles with Self Insurance Services, LLC. The staff always reviews our renewals and makes sure the rates remain the same or shop us out to one of their other providers, to keep the rates very competitive. We are extremely happy with the service they provide to us as well."

Dr. Tony Wells, Newburgh, IN